Best Engagement Rings: Say "Yes!" To These Stunning Styles

Choosing an engagement ring is a major decision as you plan the perfect proposal. From sparkly, statement-making stunners to beautifully understated vintage engagement rings, there's a ring to express every couple's personal style, especially when you shop from independent jewelers on Etsy who specialize in creating unique engagement ring designs. Here are our top picks for engagement rings from small shops on Etsy.

Dainty engagement rings

Dainty engagement rings may be small in size, but they make up for it with their details. With their delicate and feminine style, these rings pack a serious punch in a petite package.

1. Diamond rhombus engagement ring

SHOP: Diamond rhombus ring from Lucy's Fine Jewelry, from $150

The pinnacle of minimalist glam, this dainty engagement ring is available in yellow, rose, and white gold in any ring size.

2. An aquamarine cluster engagement ring

SHOP: Aquamarine oval engagement ring with diamond banding from W2N Jewelry, $316

Gaze into this beautiful cluster ring featuring tiny diamond accents and a show-stopping aquamarine gem. This is an especially exceptional pick if it’s your spouse-to-be’s birthstone—hello, March babies!

3. A delicate rose ring

SHOP: Solid gold diamond rose ring from Mary John Fine Jewelry, $340

This rose gold ring boasts a feminine, floral shape that will charm your loved one the same way they charmed you.

4. A gold and sapphire engagement ring

SHOP: Minimalist sapphire engagement ring from Marcia Vidal Jewellery, from $593

A simple yet stunning twist on a classic, minimalist engagement ring, this handcrafted engagement ring flaunts September’s birthstone, sapphire.

Vintage-style engagement rings

Vintage engagement rings) can be ornate or understated, but they are always unique and always come with a story. These picks for the best vintage and vintage-inspired engagement rings sparkle with the love stories of decades past.

5. A classic diamond solitaire ring

SHOP: Old European-cut solitaire engagement ring from Jean Jean Vintage, from $2,300

This old European-cut diamond engagement ring sparkles and twinkles as it reflects the light just so—proving an eye-catching diamond can really stand on its own. This solitaire ring’s white gold banding adds sophistication and precision to a truly stunning ring.

6. A kite diamond engagement ring

SHOP: Salt and pepper kite diamond engagement ring from Hiddenspace Jewelry, from $3,130

This salt and pepper diamond is hand-picked and set by the Etsy seller, making it truly one-of-a-kind. Bonus: You can have a matching wedding band added to your order for a pretty, vintage-inspired bridal set.

Tip: Thanks new flexible payment options from Klarna for select items on Etsy, US-based buyers can start planning their wedding now and pay for their dream ring later (terms and conditions apply).

7. A modern claddagh ring

SHOP: Gold claddagh engagement ring from OOZA Jewelry, from $1,200

A traditional Irish design, the claddagh ring is imbued with symbolism: The hands represent friendship, the heart is true love, and the crown symbolizes loyalty—all foundations of a strong marriage. This modern take on the claddagh features a moissanite heart and baguette diamond crown, so this ring has sparkle and soul.

8. Teal sapphire engagement ring

SHOP: Teal sapphire engagement ring with diamond wedding band from Diorah Jewellery, from $1,738

Sapphire engagement rings became much more popular since Kate Middleton donned one that belonged to the late Princess Diana, and this gorgeous teal sapphire engagement ring is worthy of royalty.

Yellow gold engagement rings

Wondering what to look for when shopping for an engagement ring? You want elegance and beauty, of course, but you also want to pick the best engagement ring to make your loved one feel oh-so-special as they wear it every day. Many modern couples choose yellow gold engagement rings because of their classic, timeless style.

9. Three-stone engagement ring

SHOP: Three-stone engagement ring from Nested Yellow, $479

Featuring a delicate band made from 14k yellow gold and a trio of zircon stones, this three-stone engagement ring’s beauty makes for an instant heirloom.

10. Modern princess cut diamond ring

SHOP: Square diamond yellow gold engagement ring from Hannah Louise Lamb Jewellery, $1,837

Handmade in Scotland, this unique engagement ring style features a square diamond with flush setting. The ring's gold band can be shiny or matte, depending on your preferences.

Non-traditional engagement rings

Whether you have a storybook love or have hit those relationship milestones your way, there’s no love quite like yours. So if a traditional solitaire diamond ring doesn’t quite feel like you, start your own tradition with these non-traditional engagement rings made just for you.

11. Earthy engagement ring

SHOP: Emerald green engagement ring from Nangijala Jewelry, $1,028

Both modern and woodsy, this ​​non-traditional engagement ring spotlights emerald green moissanite set in a solid 14k yellow gold setting.

12. Neutral-toned cluster engagement ring

SHOP: Salt and pepper diamond and pink sapphire engagement ring CJ bijoux, $1,480

This cluster ring has it all: It’s both sophisticated and playful, offers traditional, neutral-colored diamonds mixed with pink sapphire accent stones, and is a statement piece worthy of any engagement.

13. Raw diamond engagement ring

SHOP: Rough diamond engagement ring with twig banding from Dawn Vertrees Jewelry, from $1,818

The cut of a diamond can catch light just-so, but raw diamonds have a texture and intrigue that makes for an unexpected, non-traditional engagement ring. This rose gold engagement ring lets the natural beauty of its rough-cut diamonds do all the talking.

14. Nature-inspired moissanite engagement ring

SHOP: Gold branch moissanite engagement ring from Nangijala Jewelry, from $1,270

The centerpiece stone always gets all the oohs and ahhs, but this engagement ring has a cleverly designed twig-like band that can get compliments on its own. With its twig-like texture and organic wrapping style, this moissanite engagement ring is a natural show-stopper.

Birthstone engagement rings

For a style with serious meaning, opt for a birthstone engagement ring featuring one or both of your birthstones. Whether she wears her own, her beloved's, or a toi-et-moi style featuring stones for each of you, a birthstone engagement ring carries extra significance.

15. Natural emerald engagement ring

SHOP: Emerald engagement ring from Rimon Fine Jewelry, from $680

May's storied gemstone of the goddess Venus, emerald is considered a symbol of love and truth. With its double gold band and sharply-shaped gemstone, this emerald engagement ring proves your love was written in the stars.

16. Blue opal engagement ring

SHOP: Blue opal and sterling silver engagement ring from Spirit Of Island, from $179

October’s birthstone is a shimmery gem with an ethereal iridescence. This true blue beauty refracts a whole rainbow of color and is set in a sterling silver band.

17. Minimalist moonstone engagement ring

SHOP: Moonstone and yellow gold engagement ring from Ana Kroll jewelry, $218

Symbolizing inner clarity and intuition, moonstone is one of June's birthstones and a perfect gem for a soulmate who always trusts their instincts (they chose you, after all!). Its yellow gold band and simple design places all the focus on soulful stone.

Oval-cut engagement rings

The oval stone shape signifies family, tradition, and individuality, so if those characteristics describe your loved one, consider an unexpected take on the circular diamond engagement ring with these oval-cut picks.

18. Oval salt and pepper diamond ring

SHOP: Salt and pepper oval diamond ring from Diorah Jewellery, from $1,383

The super-chic simplicity of this oval engagement ring leaves the beauty of the salt and pepper diamond to take center stage—talk about a minimalist marvel!

19. Oval alexandrite engagement ring

SHOP: Teardrop-shaped alexandrite engagement ring from Kate Szabone Jewellery, $1,307

A mesmerizing, color-changing gemstone, alexandrite will captivate your loved one with its kaleidoscopic qualities. With the beauty of the gem and its intricately detailed setting, you’ll be admiring this oval engagement ring for years to come.

20. Oval aquamarine engagement ring

SHOP: Natural aquamarine diamond engagement ring from Amulette Boutique, from $1,811

This aquamarine and diamond ring has tiny hand-stamped lines around the central stone to create a lived-in texture, and the sideways oval shape is an unexpected take on your standard engagement ring.

Minimalist engagement rings

Maybe you and your partner don’t want the razzle-dazzle that comes with the more decadent engagement rings. These modern, minimalist picks are both elegant and understated—proving sometimes less really is more.

21. Modern white gold engagement ring

SHOP: White gold wedding band from Elizabeth Leflar, from $73

For a sleek and sophisticated look, use this modern white gold wedding band as an engagement ring to really cater to a minimalist's heart.

22. Minimalist solitaire engagement ring

SHOP: Solitaire engagement ring from ANMA, from $663

This minimalist engagement ring is easily stackable, so choosing a wedding band should be a breeze.

23. Star-studded minimalist engagement band

SHOP: Diamond-encrusted engagement band from Foe & Dear, from $424

For those looking for a lot of sparkle without a giant gemstone, this celestial-inspired engagement band twinkles like the clear night sky in the summertime.

24. Baguette engagement ring

SHOP: Unique baguette engagement ring from MICHAL BENDZEL, from $1,690

Don’t call it a comeback! The baguette diamond ring was first introduced in the roaring ‘20s for an Art Deco look, but this modern take on the baguette ring is a stunning stacking ring that will play nicely with your other jewelry.

25. Clear white sapphire engagement ring

SHOP: Rose-cut sapphire engagement ring from Nangijala Jewelry, $1,350

With its simple-but-sunny golden band and circular setting, this rose-cut white sapphire engagement ring is a vision in bloom.

Best engagement ring FAQs

Shopping for the best engagement ring? Here are a few things to keep in mind before popping the question.

What are the best engagement rings?

Whether you’re looking for a delicate diamond engagement ring or something a little different like a modern birthstone ring, the best engagement rings reflect your significant other’s individual personality, style, and aesthetic. And just like the love you have for each other, the ring you choose should be one that will last for a lifetime!

Where are the best places to buy an engagement ring?

When you're shopping online for an engagement ring, look to the small shops on Etsy to find the widest range of styles and price points, from vintage pieces with a love story all their own to custom engagement rings designed especially for you. When you work with an Etsy shop to design an engagement ring—from the setting to the stones—you'll create an heirloom-worthy piece that perfectly expresses your unique love story.

How much should you spend on an engagement ring?

Engagement rings can be a big investment, so the most important thing is to find a ring you, and your beloved, will adore. Quality and distinctiveness are important qualities to consider when deciding how much to spend on an engagement ring. The common advice is that you spend a few month’s salary on an engagement ring. If you're searching for a special engagement ring, the engagement rings from small shops on Etsy are lovingly crafted by real people with a passion for making unique engagement rings to fit any type of style, personality, and price point.